Posted: May 19, 2021
| NFCA Release |
FIRST TEAM
| POS | Name | School |
| Pitcher | Nikki Camarati | Baldwin Wallace |
| Outfield | Brooklyn Hellman | Mount Union |
| Outfield | Grace Heath | Mount Union |
SECOND TEAM
| POS | Name | School |
| UTL/Pitcher | Alyssa Rose | Mount Unoin |
THIRD TEAM
| POS | Name | School |
| First Base | Allie Goldy | Mount Union |
| Second Base | Karsyn Shaffer | Muskingum |
