Posted: Jun 22, 2021
| First team offense | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| QB | Braxton Plunk | Mount Union | So. | Plant City, Fla. |
| RB | Darian Greeley | Bluffton | Jr. | Belleville, Mich. |
| RB | Austin DeNoyer | Martin Luther | Sr. | Lake Mills, Wis. |
| WR | Maceo Matthews | Heidelberg | Sr. | Miami, Fla. |
| WR | Wayne Ruby | Mount Union | Jr. | Miami, Fla. |
| TE | Alex Lopez | Benedictine | Sr. | Elmwood Park, Ill. |
| T | Joseph Osborne | Salisbury | Sr. | St. Leonard, Md. |
| G | Boomer Warren | Hardin-Simmons | Jr. | Haslet, Texas |
| C | Steven Sellers | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Murphy, Texas |
| G | Sean Pogorelc | Carnegie Mellon | Sr. | Centreville, Va. |
| T | Blake Herideen | John Carroll | Sr. | Akron, Ohio |
| First team defense | ||||
| DE | Drake Neuberger | Marietta | Jr. | Norwalk, Ohio |
| DT | Richard Pope IV | Defiance | Fr. | Daytona Beach, Fla. |
| DT | Blade Durbala | Central | Sr. | Blairstown, Iowa |
| DE | Mike Murphy | Illinois Wesleyan | Sr. | Orland Park, Ill. |
| DE | Brayden Thimons | Westminster (Pa.) | Jr. | Natrona Heights, Pa. |
| LB | Akeem Jackson | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Fairfield, Texas |
| LB | Ian Barr | Westminster (Pa.) | Jr. | State College, Pa. |
| LB | Brett Tharp | Bridgewater | Jr. | Baker, W.Va. |
| CB | Devin Grier | Berry | Jr. | Lawrenceville, Ga. |
| S | Jefferson Fritz | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Kaufman, Texas |
| S | KJ Kelley | East Texas Baptist | Jr. | Abilene, Texas |
| CB | Montez Archer Jr. | Bluffton | Fr. | Detroit, Mich. |
| First team specialists | ||||
| K | Juan Ocampo | Texas Lutheran | Jr. | Lockhart, Texas |
| P | Jefferson Fritz | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Kaufman, Texas |
| RET | A.J. Jackson | Lake Forest | So. | Peoria, Ariz. |
| ST | Tristin Quick | Averett | Sr. | Charlotte, N.C. |
| Second team offense | ||||
| QB | Kyle Jones | Hardin-Simmons | Sr. | Giddings, Texas |
| RB | Shane Welshans | Rose-Hulman | Jr. | Robards, Ky. |
| RB | Devin Briscoe | Louisiana College | Jr. | Cecilia, La. |
| WR | Colton Lockwood | Millikin | Jr. | Decatur, Ill. |
| WR | Jake Parker | Howard Payne | Sr. | Whitehouse, Texas |
| TE | Ed Newman | Hampden-Sydney | Sr. | Farmville, Va. |
| T | Will Jackson | Randolph-Macon | Jr. | Biscoe, N.C. |
| G | Jeffery Sims, Jr. | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Jr. | Mesquite, Texas |
| C | Jake Buhe | Illinois Wesleyan | Jr. | Frankfort, Ill. |
| G | Angelo Fratini | Washington & Jefferson | So. | Burgettstown, Pa. |
| T | Nike Gooden | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Bryan, Texas |
| Second team defense | ||||
| DE | Andrew Hesse | Rose-Hulman | Sr. | Loveland, Ohio |
| DT | Kyle Gallagher | Marietta | Sr. | Chesterland, Ohio |
| DT | Adonnis Butler | Hendrix | Sr. | DeSoto, Texas |
| DE | Jay Swegheimer | Emory & Henry | So. | Orlando, Fla. |
| LB | Shane Quin | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Chardon, Ohio |
| LB | Mikkah Hackett | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Alto, Texas |
| LB | Tavion Bryant | Wilmington | Sr. | Columbus, Ohio |
| CB | Joc Pledger | Brevard | So. | Monroe, Ga. |
| S | Jesse Vail | Mount Union | Jr. | Estero, Fla. |
| S | Bryce Thomas | Westminster (Pa.) | Jr. | St. Mary's, Ga. |
| CB | Tramon Wiley | Heidelberg | Jr. | Eastpointe, Mich. |
| Second team specialists | ||||
| K | Chris Vidal | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Wake Forest, N.C. |
| P | Ethan Hoffman | George Fox | So. | Medford, Ore. |
| RET | Zahir Wilder | Montclair State | Sr. | Rahway, N.J. |
| ST | Danny Baker | Lake Forest | So. | Winnetka, Ill. |
