| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Capf | 3-7 | on Ott48 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Capf | 3-7 | on Ott48 | B. Everson pass incomplete to M. Smith, QB hurry by Conner Buchanan. |
| Capf | 4-7 | on Ott48 | Clock 14:49. |
| Capf | 4-7 | on Ott48 | K. Lee punt 36 yards to the OTT12, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 1:18 |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott12 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 14:40. |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott12 | Logan Pharmer at QB for Otterbein. |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott12 | J. Bost-Floyd rush for 3 yards to the OTT15 (N. Fisanick). |
| Ott | 2-7 | on Ott15 | Logan Pharmer pass incomplete to Nate Hall (N. Fisanick). |
| Ott | 3-7 | on Ott15 | Logan Pharmer rush for 1 yard to the OTT16 (K. Swackhammer;J. Blaisdell). |
| Ott | 4-6 | on Ott16 | Timeout Otterbein, clock 13:09. |
| Ott | 4-6 | on Ott16 | Adyn Snyder punt 42 yards to the CAPF42, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 1:45 |
| Capf | 1-10 | on Capf42 | CAPITAL drive start at 12:55. |
| Capf | 1-10 | on Capf42 | A. Ray at QB for Capital. |
| Capf | 1-10 | on Capf42 | D. Schoonover rush for 1 yard to the CAPF43 (Alex Keister). |
| Capf | 2-9 | on Capf43 | A. Ray pass incomplete to A. Everson. |
| Capf | 3-9 | on Capf43 | D. Schoonover rush for 4 yards to the CAPF47 (Colton Doup). |
| Capf | 4-5 | on Capf47 | K. Lee punt 48 yards to the OTT5, fair catch by Max Walden. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 1:39 |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott05 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 11:16. |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott05 | Patrick Beck rush for 4 yards to the OTT9 (M. Vujaklija;B. Appiarius). |
| Ott | 2-6 | on Ott09 | Patrick Beck rush for 2 yards to the OTT11 (C. Fox;B. Newsome). |
| Ott | 3-4 | on Ott11 | Patrick Beck rush for loss of 3 yards to the OTT8 (B. Appiarius;B. Newsome). |
| Ott | 4-7 | on Ott08 | Adyn Snyder punt 52 yards to the CAPF40, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 2:37 |
| Capf | 1-10 | on Capf40 | CAPITAL drive start at 08:39. |
| Capf | 1-10 | on Capf40 | D. Schoonover rush for 1 yard to the CAPF41 (K. Carter-Stoke). |
| Capf | 2-9 | on Capf41 | D. Schoonover rush for no gain to the CAPF41 (Alex Keister;Max Walden). |
| Capf | 3-9 | on Capf41 | A. Ray pass complete to L. Hayes for 5 yards to the CAPF46, out-of-bounds, QB hurry by Nick Cipriano. |
| Capf | 4-4 | on Capf46 | J. Zweydorff punt 26 yards to the OTT28, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 2:16 |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott28 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 06:23. |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott28 | Jay Bradley rush for 5 yards to the OTT33 (S. Dupont). |
| Ott | 2-5 | on Ott33 | Jay Bradley rush for no gain to the OTT33 (K. Swackhammer;W. Long). |
| Ott | 3-5 | on Ott33 | Logan Pharmer pass complete to D. Currelly-Joh for 7 yards to the OTT40, 1ST DOWN OTT (Q. Edwards). |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Ott40 | TEAM rush for loss of 10 yards to the OTT30. |
| Ott | 2-20 | on Ott30 | Jay Bradley rush for 1 yard to the OTT31 (R. Chadeya;T. Zimmer). |
| Ott | 3-19 | on Ott31 | Jay Bradley rush for 10 yards to the OTT41 (L. Hoersten). |
| Ott | 4-9 | on Ott41 | Adyn Snyder punt 30 yards to the CAPF29, M. Smith return 0 yards to the CAPF29, fumble by M. Smith recovered by OTT D. Currelly-Joh at CAPF27. |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 13 yards, TOP 4:41 |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Capf27 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 01:42. |
| Ott | 1-10 | on Capf27 | PENALTY OTT delay of game 5 yards to the CAPF32. |
| Ott | 1-15 | on Capf32 | TEAM rush for loss of 3 yards to the CAPF35. |
| Ott | 2-18 | on Capf35 | TEAM rush for loss of 4 yards to the CAPF39. |
| Ott | 3-22 | on Capf39 | TEAM rush for loss of 4 yards to the CAPF43. |
| Ott | 4-26 | on Capf43 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, minus 16 yards, TOP 1:42 |
