| Date | Otterbein 27, Ohio Northern 15 | ||
| 11.13.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jackson Lakso, OTT | Dec 5-3 | Seth Transue, ONU |
| 133 | Ryan Jakubiak, OTT | Forfeit | |
| 141 | Santino DiSabato, OTT | Dec 4-1 | Brandon Bartlome, ONU |
| 149 | Jeff Andrews, ONU | Fall 2:29 | Hunter Thornsberry, ONU |
| 157 | Dylan Dolph, ONU | Dec 8-1 | Michael Duzzny, OTT |
| 165 | Zach Altman, OTT | Dec 7-4 | Schuyler Caprella, ONU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Fall 3:27 | Joey Bradberry, OTT |
| 184 | Jarrod Setliff, OTT | Dec 10-5 | Cash Thompson, ONU |
| 197 | Corbin Bunsold, OTT | Dec 8-2 | Chase Gibson, ONU |
| 285 | Drew Kasper, OTT | Fall :34 | Austin Keeley, ONU |
| Date | John Carroll 39, Muskingum 11 | ||
| 11.13.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jordan Burkholder, MUSK | TF 18-3 | Kyle Murray, JCU |
| 133 | Spencer Dusi, JCU | Forfeit | |
| 141 | Jarrod Brezovec, JCU | Fall 2:39 | Cooper Hemming, MUSK |
| 149 | Ian McKenna, JCU | Dec 9-2 | Toby Warrington, MUSK |
| 157 | Drew Benos, JCU | Forfeit | |
| 165 | Tanner Walker, MUSK | SV-1 3-1 | Luke Reicosky, JCU |
| 174 | Sam Gross, JCU | Forfeit | |
| 184 | Russ Porter, JCU | Fall 3:26 | Carter Layton, MUSK |
| 197 | Garrett Mitchel, MUSK | Dec 3-2 | Darrell Lane, JCU |
| 285 | Luca Santillo, JCU | Fall 2:34 | Cody Jenkins, MUSK |
| Date | Mount Union 31, Baldwin Wallace 14 | ||
| 11.13.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Nolan Wochna, MTU | Fall 4:22 | Chad Craft, BW |
| 133 | Jordin James, MTU | MD 21-12 | Dante Ginnetti, BW |
| 141 | David Massey, MTU | Dec 5-2 | Charlie Nash, BW |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | Dec 14-7 | Luke Hernandez, MTU |
| 157 | Antwon Pugh, Jr., MTU | Fall 2:12 | Richie Burke, BW |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | Dec 8-7 | Michael McIntire, MTU |
| 174 | Jairod James, MTU | Inj 1:37 | Benjamin Hooff, BW |
| 184 | Justin Ransom, BW | MD 16-5 | Rob Valenti, MTU |
| 197 | Zeckary Lehman, BW | MD 12-4 | Tyler Stepic, MTU |
| 285 | Grant Martin, MTU | Fall 3:13 | Zachary Baker, BW |
| Date | Baldwin Wallace 35, John Carroll 6 | ||
| 11.27.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Chad Craft, BW | Dec 7-3 | Andrew Perelk, JCU |
| 133 | Dante Ginnetti, BW | Fall 3:00 | Iain Whitis, JCU |
| 141 | Tanner Mchugh, BW | Dec 5-4 | Jarrod Brezovec, JCU |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | Dec 8-3 | Jarrod Lasko, JCU |
| 157 | Richard Burke, BW | TF 16-0 | Shane Ging, JCU |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | TF 17-1 | Luke Reicosky, JCU |
| 174 | Sam Gross, JCU | Dec 13-6 | Adam Green, BW |
| 184 | Justin Ransom, BW | MD 22-8 | Vittorio Santillo, JCU |
| 197 | Zeckary Lehman, BW | Fall 3:00 | Russ Porter, JCU |
| 285 | Luca Santillo, JCU | Dec 10-8 | James Ritchie, BW |
| Date | Heidelberg 22, Ohio Northern 18 | ||
| 11.27.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Seth Transue, ONU | Dec 11-10 | Pacer Quire, HEID |
| 133 | Mason Brainhard, HEID | MD 15-5 | Canerib Poulton, ONU |
| 141 | Tre Bogetich, HEID | Dec 3-1 | Brandon Bartlome, ONU |
| 149 | Jeff Andrews, ONU | Dec 9-8 | Slade Todd, HEID |
| 157 | Schuyler Caprella, ONU | Dec 9-5 | Devin Miller, HEID |
| 165 | Dante Colza, HEID | MD 12-1 | Jordan Hardrick, ONU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Pin (5:41) | Jeremiah Slagle, HEID |
| 184 | Dylan Roth, HEID | Pin (:52) | Cash Thompson, ONU |
| 197 | Tyler Hammack, HEID | TF 20-2 | Chase Gibson, ONU |
| 285 | Austin Keeley, ONU | Dec 4-1 | Christian Climer, HEID |
| Date | Mount Union 38, Otterbein 11 | ||
| 11.27.18 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jackson Lakso, OTT | Dec 3-2 | Nolan Wochna, MTU |
| 133 | Jordin James, MTU | TF 17-0 | Ryan Jakubiak, OTT |
| 141 | David Massey,MTU | Forfeit | |
| 149 | Luke Hernandez, MTU | Forfeit | |
| 157 | Antwon Pugh, Jr., MTU | Fall (:18) | Michael Duzzny, OTT |
| 165 | Michael McIntire, MTU | Fall (:30) | Joey Bradberry, OTT |
| 174 | Jairod James, MTU | TF 21-6 | Denver Aydelott, OTT |
| 184 | Rob Valenti, MTU | MD 14-5 | Jarrod Setliff, OTT |
| 197 | Corbin Bunsold, OTT | MD 14-3 | Tyler Stepic, MTU |
| 285 | Drew Kasper, OTT | Dec 14-6 | Grant Martin, MTU |
| Date | John Carroll 25, Otterbein 21 | ||
| 1.15.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Andrew Perelka, JCU | For | |
| 133 | Jackson Lakso, OTT | Dec 6-3 | Spencer Dusi, JCU |
| 141 | Jarrod Brezovec, JCU | Dec 7-2 | Santino DiSabato, OTT |
| 149 | Jarrod Lasko, JCU | Fall 3:56 | Michael Duzzny, OTT |
| 157 | Daniel Novak, JCU | MD 11-3 | Joey Bradberry, OTT |
| 165 | Sam Gross, JCU | Fall 4:22 | Dylan Gray, OTT |
| 174 | Donny Didion, OTT | Fall 6:26 | Jimmy Suhayda, JCU |
| 184 | Jarrod Setliff, OTT | Dec 7-1 | Christina Hipsher, JCU |
| 197 | Corbin Bunsold, OTT | Fall 1:45 | Darrell Lane, JCU |
| 285 | Drew Kasper, OTT | Dec 7-1 | Luca Santillo, JCU |
| Date | Mount Union 39, Heidelberg 6 | ||
| 1.15.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Seth Hayes, MTU | Fall 2:27 | Pacer Quire, HEID |
| 133 | Jordin James, MTU | SV-1 10-8 | Mason Brainard, HEID |
| 141 | David Massey, MTU | DEC 4-3 | Richard Bogetich, HEID |
| 149 | Luke Hernandez, MTU | TF 21-6 | Slade Todd, HEID |
| 157 | Antwon Pugh, MTU | Fall 0:37 | Jacob Horsch, HEID |
| 165 | Michael McIntire, MTU | Fall 1:29 | Micah Mydloski, HEID |
| 174 | Jairod James, MTU | Fall 4:52 | Jeremiah Slagle, HEID |
| 184 | Dylan Roth, HEID | Dec 10-5 | Rob Valenti, MTU |
| 197 | Tyler Hammack, HEID | Dec 5-2 | Landon Talbert, MTU |
| 285 | Nick Corvo, MTU | MD 10-0 | Blake Jerome, HEID |
| Date | Ohio Northern 39, Muskingum 12 | ||
| 1.15.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jordan Burkholder, MUSK | For | |
| 133 | Cameron Poulton, ONU | For | |
| 141 | Brandon Bartlone, ONU | Pin 1:32 | Cooper Hemming |
| 149 | Jeff Andrews, ONU | Dec 8-2 | Toby Warrington 8-2 |
| 157 | Schuyler Caprella, ONU | For | |
| 165 | Tanner Walker, MUSK | Dec 5-3 | Dylan Dolph, ONU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Pin1:12 | Carter Layton, MUSK |
| 184 | Cash Thompson, ONU | For | |
| 197 | Connor Kwiat, ONU | For | |
| 285 | Antonio Zapata, MUSK | Dec 7-1 | Chris Mueller, ONU |
| Date | Baldwin Wallace 51, Muskingum 3 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jordan Burkholder, MUSK | Dec 6-0 | Nicholas Berry, BW |
| 133 | Dante Ginnetti, BW | For | |
| 141 | Tanner Mchugh, BW | For | |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | MD 12-3 | Toby Warrington, MUSK |
| 157 | Richard Burke, BW | For | |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | TF 19-2 | Tanner Walker, MUSK |
| 174 | Adam Green, BW | Fall 0:31 | Carter Layton, Muskingum |
| 184 | Justin Ransom, BW | Fall 0:25 | Michael Kashuba, MUSK |
| 197 | Christopher Head, BW | For | |
| 285 | James Ritchie, BW | Fall 2:28 | Edgar Solano, MUSK |
| Date | Baldwin Wallace 36, Otterbein 7 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Nicholas Berry, BW | For | |
| 133 | Charles Nash, BW | Dec 2-0 | Jackson Lakso, OTT |
| 141 | Tanner Mchugh,BW | Dec 6-3 | Santino DiSabato, OTT |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | MD 18-5 | Michael Duzzny, OTT |
| 157 | Richard Burke, BW | TF 16-0 | Joey Bradberry, OTT |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | Fall 1:10 | Denver Aydelott, OTT |
| 174 | Donny Didion, OTT | Dec 6-4 | Adam Green, BW |
| 184 | Justin Ransom, BW | For | |
| 197 | Christopher Head, BW | Dec 9-4 | Luke Hess, OTT |
| 285 | Drew Kasper, OTT | MD 10-2 | James Ritchie, BW |
| Date | Baldwin Wallace 27, Heidelberg 14 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Pacer Quire, Heidelberg | Dec 11-5 | Nicholas Berry, BW |
| 133 | Dante Ginnetti, BW | Dec 12-6 | Mason Brainard, HEID |
| 141 | Tanner Mchugh, BW | Dec 6-5 | Richard Bogetich, HEID |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | MD 16-4 | Slade Todd, HEID |
| 157 | Richard Burke, BW | TF 18-0 | Jacob Horsch, HEID |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | Fall 2:37 | Micah Mydolski, HEID |
| 174 | Jeremiah Slagle, HEID | Dec 10-6 | Adam Green, BW |
| 184 | Dylan Roth, HEID | Dec 10-4 | Justin Ransom, BW |
| 197 | Tyer Hammack, HEID | TF 18-2 | Christopher Head, BW |
| 285 | James Ritchie, BW | Fall 2:35 | Christian Climer, HEID |
| Date | Mount Union 34, Ohio Northern 13 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Seth Hayes, MTU | For | |
| 133 | Jodin James, MTU | TF 20-5 | Cameron Poulton, ONU |
| 141 | David Massey, MTU | For | |
| 149 | Luke Hernandez, MTU | MD 12-3 | Jeff Andrews, ONU |
| 157 | Antwon Pugh, MTU | Fall 2:17 | Scuyler Caprella, ONU |
| 165 | Michael McIntire, MTU | MD 12-2 | Jordan Hardrick, ONU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Fall 1:55 | Conner Homan, MTU |
| 184 | Cash Thompson, ONU | MD 12-3 | Tyler Stepic, MTU |
| 197 | Landon Talbert, MTU | Dec 7-0 | Christopher Mueller, ONU |
| 285 | Austin Keeley, ONU | SV-1 3-1 | Assante Ndongo, MTU |
| Date | Mount Union 41, John Carroll 6 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Andrew Perelka, JCU | Fall 3:36 | Seth Hayes,MTU |
| 133 | Jordin James, MTU | TF 16-0 | Spencer Dursi, JCU |
| 141 | David Massey, MTU | Dec 5-1 | Jeff Brichford, JCU |
| 149 | Luke Hernandez, MTU | Fall 2:24 | Jarrod Lasko, JCU |
| 157 | Antwon Pugh, MTU | TF 18-0 | Daniel Novak, JCU |
| 165 | Michael McIntire, MTU | Dec 7-0 | Sam Gross, JCU |
| 174 | Connor Homan, MTU | Fall 0:44 | Vittorio Santillo, JCU |
| 184 | Tyler Stepic, MTU | Dec 13-5 | Christian Hipsher, JCU |
| 197 | Landon Talbert, MTU | Fall 2:58 | Russ Porter, JCU |
| 285 | Nick Corvo, MTU | Dec 12-9 | Josh Stasek, MTU |
| Date | John Carroll 30, Ohio Northern 9 | ||
| 1.19.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Kyle Murray, JCU | For | |
| 133 | Andrew Pereklka, JCU | Fall 4:16 | Cameron Poulton, ONU |
| 141 | Spencer Dusi, JCU | Fall 4:37 | Brandon Bartlome, ONU |
| 149 | Jarrod Lasko, JCU | Dec 4-3 | Jeff Andrews, ONU |
| 157 | Daniel Novak, JCU | Dec 5-3 | Schuyler Caprella, OU |
| 165 | Jordan Handrick, ONU | Dec 7-4 | Seth Winkle, JCU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Dec 6-0 | Jimmy Suhayda, JCU |
| 184 | Cash Thompson, ONU | Dec 3-2 | Vittorio Santillo, JCU |
| 197 | Christian Hipsher, JCU | Dec 6-2 | Christopher Mueller, ONU |
| 285 | Josh Stasek, JCU | Dec 4-2 | Austin Keeley, ONU |
| Date | Mount Union 43, Muskingum 9 | ||
| 2.5.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Jordan Burkholder, MUSK | Fall 1:12 | Seth Hayes |
| 133 | Leondre Cooley, MTU | For | |
| 141 | David Massey, MTU | For | |
| 149 | Luke Hernandez, MTU | MD 17-7 | Toby Warrington, MUSk |
| 157 | Justin Rayner, MTU | For | |
| 165 | Michael McIntire, MTU | Dec 3-1 | Tanner Walker, MUSK |
| 174 | Conner Homan, MTU | Fall 1:14 | Michael Kashuba,MUSK |
| 184 | Rob Valenti, MTU | Fall 4:28 | Carter Layton, MUSK |
| 197 | Landon Talbert, MTU | For | |
| 285 | Antonio Zapata, MUSK | Dec 16-10 | Nick Corvo, MTU |
| Date | John Carroll 23, Heidelberg 19 | ||
| 2.5.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Andrew Perelka, JCU | MD 11-2 | Pacer Quire, HEID |
| 133 | Mason Brainard, HEID | Dec 8-1 | Spencer Dusi, JCU |
| 141 | Jarrod Brezovec, JCU | TF 20-3 | Tre Bogetich, HEID |
| 149 | Jarrad Lasko, JCU | TF 15-0 | Dwight Parker, HEID |
| 157 | Danny Novak, JCU | Dec 9-5 | Jacob Horsch, HEID |
| 165 | Seth Winkle, JCU | Pin 2:16 | Micah Mydolski, HEID |
| 174 | Jeremiah Slagle, HEID | MD 17-5 | Sam Gross, JCU |
| 184 | Dylan Roth, HEID | MD 12-3 | Luke Reicosky, JCU |
| 197 | Tyler Hammack, HEID | TF 15-0 | Vittorio Santillo, JCU |
| 285 | Christian Climer, HEID | Dec 6-3 | Joshua Stasek, JCU |
| Date | Baldwin Wallace 46, Ohio Northern 6 | ||
| 2.8.19 | |||
| Wt. | Winner | Result | Opponet |
| 125 | Nicholas Berry, BW | For | |
| 133 | Charles Nash, BW | For | |
| 141 | Dalton Leightner, BW | Pin 3:00 | Brandon Bartlome, ONU |
| 149 | Stanley Bleich, BW | Dec 12-5 | Jeff Andrews, ONU |
| 157 | Richard Burke, BW | Pin 0:42 | Rhett Roeder, ONU |
| 165 | Anthony Arroyo, BW | TF 15-0 | Jordan Hardrick, ONU |
| 174 | Clayton Davidson, ONU | Pin 2:48 | Ryan Orr, BW |
| 184 | Justin Ransom, BW | MD 12-3 | Cash Thompson, ONU |
| 197 | Zechary Lehman, BW | MD 10-2 | Chris Mueller, ONU |
| 285 | James Ritchie, BW | Pin 2:32 | Austin Keeley, ONU |