| Single-Game Individual | |
| Most Points, 69, John Rinka, Kenyon (vs. Wooster) | 1969-70 |
| Field Goals Attempted, 43, John Rinka, Kenyon (vs. Wooster) | 1969-70 |
| Field Goals Made (27) John Rinka, Kenyon (vs. Wooster) | 1969-70 |
| Field Goal Percentage (10 or more), 1.000 (11-11), Amara Toure', Baldwin-Wallace (vs. Bethany) | 1997-98 |
| Field Goal Percentage (10 or more), 1.000 (11-11), Jason Dutcher, Otterbein (vs. Heidelberg) | 1999-00 |
| Free Throws Attempted, 29, John Leohner, Otterbein (vs. Ohio Wesleyan) | 1958-59 |
| a-Free Throws Made, 25, John Leohner, Otterbein (vs. Ohio Wesleyan) | 1958-59 |
| a-Free Throws Made, 25, George Cowell, Marietta (vs. Rio Grande) | 1955-56 |
| b-Free Throws Attempted, 25, Tyler Ousley, Otterbein (vs. Muskingum) | 2006-07 |
| b-Free Throws Made, 22, Tyler Ousley, Otterbein (vs. Muskingum) | 2006-07 |
| Free Throw Pct. (min. 12 made) |1.000 (18-18), Henry Fowler, Heidelberg (vs. Akron) | 1962-63 |
| Most Rebounds, 36, Don DeJong, Denison (vs. Otterbein) | 1951-52 |
| Most Assists, 19, Brett Freshour, Heidelberg (vs. Otterbein) | 1980-81 |
| Most Steals, 10, Josh Jakacki, Hiram (vs. Gannon) | 1997-98 |
| Most Steals, 10, Kelley McClure, Otterbein (vs. MacMurray) | 1995-96 |
| Most Blocked Shots, 10, Brad Baldridge, Wittenberg (vs. Heidelberg) | 1988-89 |
| Most Blcoked Shots, 10, John Lampe, Hiram (vs. Theil) | 1991-92 |
| Most Three-Point Field Goals Attempted, 24, Jackson Sartain, John Carroll (vs.Keuka College) | 2021-22 |
| Most Three-Point Field Goals Made, 15, Jackson Sartain, John Carroll (vs. Keuka College) | 2021-22 |
| Three-Point FG% (min. 10 attempts), .800 (8-10), Jackson Sartain, John Carroll (vs. Capital) | 2018-19 |
| a-Records established before the 1972-73 season. | |
| b-Records established since the 1972-73 season when the common foul free throw rule went into effect. | |
| Single-Game Team | |
| Most Points, 148, Muskingum vs. University of Redlands | 2005-06 |
| Most Points, two teams, 277, Otterbein, 141 vs.Emory & Henry, 136 | 2007-08 |
| Field Goals Attempted, 33, Denison vs. Rio Grande | 1949-50 |
| Field Goals Made, 66, Ohio Northern vs. Midwestern Baptist | 1978-79 |
| Field-Goal Percentage, 794, Muskingum vs. Kenyon | 1982-83 |
| a-Free Throws Attempted, 69, Akron vs. Marietta | 1956-57 |
| a-Free Throws Made, 50, Denison vs. Capital | 1956-57 |
| b-Free Throws Attempted, 55, Wittenberg vs. Heidelberg | 1979-80 |
| b-Free Throws Made, 43, Capital vs. Va. Wesleyan | 1981-82 |
| Free Throw Pct. (min. 15 made), 1.000 (19-19), Marietta vs. Ohio Northern | 2001-02 |
| Free Throw Pct. (min. 15 made), 1.000 (17-17) .............Muskingum vs. Otterbein | 2003-04 |
| Most Rebounds, 93, Akron vs. Baldwin-Wallace | 1963-64 |
| Most Assists, 39, Capital vs. Marietta | 2004-05 |
| Most Steals, 30, Marietta vs. Buffalo | 2005-06 |
| Most Blocked Shots, 15, Heidelberg vs. Marietta | 2006-07 |
| Three-Pointers Attempted, 63, Marietta vs. Baldwin-Wallace | 2004-05 |
| Three-Pointers Made, 21, Muskingum vs.Heidelberg | 2005-06 |
| Three-Point FG% (min. 15 attempts), .702 (19-27), Wilmington vs. Baldwin-Wallace | 2003-04 |
| a-Records established before the 1972-73 season. | |
| b-Records established since the 1972-73 season when the common foul free throw rule went into effect. |
| Miscellaneous Records | Career | |||
| Assists | 613 | Jerry Dennis, Otterbein | 1988-92 |
| Steals | 256 | Jerry Dennis, Otterbein | 1988-92 |
| 256 | Kevin Weakley, Otterbein | 1995-99 | |
| Blocked Shots | 268 | Jeff Gibbs, Otterbein | 1998-02 |
| 3FG Attempts | 845 | Jackson Sartain, John Carroll | 2018-22 |
| 3FG Made | 390 | Jackson Sartain, John Carroll | 2018-22 |
| 3FG % | 0.462 | Jackson Sartain, John Carroll | 2018-22 |
| Most Overtime Games Played | 5 | Muskingum | 1994-95 |
| Most Overtime OAC Games Played | 4 | Muskingum | 1994-95 |
| Most Consecutive OT OAC Games Played | 5 | Muskingum, 1994-95 | 1994-95 |
| Longest Game Played | 5OT | Marietta vs. Capital | 1948-49 |
| Muskingum vs. Capital | 1979-80 | ||
| Most Consecutive Field Goals Made | 24 | Todd Richards, Mount Union * | 1999-00 |
| Consecutive Free Throws Made | 52 | Jerry Prestier, Baldwin Wallace | 1977-78 |
*NCAA Div. III Record
