Ten have earned ABCA/Rawling All-Mideast Region honors, announced on May 28. The teams are voted on by members of the American Baseball Coaches Association and the process is led by the ABCA NCAA Div. III All-America Committee.
Baldwin Wallace senior Danny Cody (Medina, OH/Brecksville-Broadview Hts.) was named the Mideast Pitcher of the year. Cody led the OAC in wins (9), earned run average (1.89), and strikeouts (109) this season and broke BW's single-season strikeout record. He made 15 appearances with 13 starts and dealt a team-high 85.2 innings. Cody was also named the D3baseball.com All-Mideast Region Pitcher of the Year and Kent Tekulve OAC Pitcher-of-the-Year.
John Carroll senior outfielder Patrick Keohane (Quincy, MA/Boston College) was voted Mideast Position Player of the Year. Keohane led the OAC in batting average (.459), on base percentage (.523), and slugging percentage (.662). Keohane posted a team-high 46 runs , along with 68 hits, 15 doubles, five home runs, and 18 stolen bases. In the field, Keohane posted a .967 percentage with 58 putouts. Keohane also garnered D3baseball.com All-Mideast Region Player of the Year and Dr. Bob Fisher OAC Player-of-the-Year honors this season.
Complete 2019 ABCA/Rawlings All-Region Teams
| 2019 Mideast-ABCA/Rawlings All-Region Teams | ||||
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Gunner Rainey | Jr. | Adrian | MI |
| 1B | Will Krushena | Jr. | Denison | OH |
| 2B | Harry Witwer-Dukes | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| 2B | Mullen Socha | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| 3B | Brian McAuliffe | Jr. | Denison | OH |
| SS | Thomas Miller | So. | Adrian | MI |
| OF | Pat Keohane | Sr. | John Carroll ** | OH |
| OF | Nick Fowkes | Sr. | Thiel | PA |
| OF | Patrick O'Leary | Jr. | Kenyon | OH |
| OF | Matt Psychas | Sr. | Heidelberg ** | OH |
| DH | Dan Harwood | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| UT | Dugan Darnell | Sr. | Adrian | MI |
| P | Mason Miller | Jr. | Waynesburg | PA |
| P | Danny Cody | Sr. | Baldwin Wallace ** | OH |
| P | Phil Mary | Sr. | Mount Union ** | OH |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Brendan Mapes | Sr. | Oberlin | OH |
| 1B | Garrett Crum | Sr. | Wooster | OH |
| 1B | Bobby Finn | Sr. | St. Vincent | PA |
| 2B | Joe Professori | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| 3B | Jacob Kucia | Sr. | Case Western Reserve | OH |
| SS | Max Lahn | So. | Denison | OH |
| SS | Jake Stuursma | Sr. | Wooster | OH |
| SS | Sam Claycamp | Sr. | Franklin | IN |
| OF | Kane Bateman | Sr. | Heidelberg ** | OH |
| OF | Jon Spina | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| OF | Gage Bley | Sr. | Wilmington ** | OH |
| OF | Dante Dalesandro | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| UT | Joe Moran | Jr. | Anderson | IN |
| P | Luke Buehler | Jr. | Rose-Hulman | IN |
| P | Nick Denove | Fr. | Case Western Reserve | OH |
| P | Tre Thomas | Jr. | La Roche | PA |
| P | Ben Marsico | Jr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| P | Max Denny | Fr. | Adrian | MI |
| P | Alex Sir Louis | Sr. | Heidelberg ** | OH |
| RP | Collin Hoffmann | Jr. | Otterbein ** | OH |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Marc Ochoa | Jr. | Heidelberg ** | OH |
| 1B | Sam Keibler | Jr. | Mount Aloysius | PA |
| 1B | Drew Naumovich | Sr. | Franklin | IN |
| 1B | Neil Woods | Sr. | Bethany | WV |
| 2B | Jordan Fairchild | Sr. | Hope | MI |
| 2B | Rocco Maue | Sr. | Case Western Reserve | OH |
| 3B | Kyle Jenkins | Jr. | Heidelberg ** | OH |
| SS | Matt McCourt | Sr. | Mount Aloysius | PA |
| OF | Jake Ryan | So. | Case Western Reserve | OH |
| OF | Ty Robinson | So. | Denison | OH |
| OF | Ryan Bixler | Jr. | Franklin | IN |
| UT | Chandler Dippman | Sr. | Wooster | OH |
| P | David Herrmann | Sr. | Hanover | IN |
| P | Garrett Mack | Sr. | Alfred State | NY |
| P | Mo Hanley | So. | Adrian | MI |
| Mideast Position Player of the Year: Pat Keohane, Sr., OF, John Carroll | ||||
| Mideast Pitcher of the Year: Danny Cody, Sr., Baldwin Wallace | ||||