Posted: May 24, 2017
| 2017 Mideast-ABCA/Rawlings All-Region Teams | ||||
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Monroe Donnelly ** | Jr. | John Carroll | OH |
| 1B | Jamie Lackner | Sr. | Wooster | OH |
| 2B | Brian Killinger | Sr. | Adrian | MI |
| 3B | Ian Velez | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| SS | Michael Wielansky | So. | Wooster | OH |
| OF | Ian Mikowski | Sr. | Adrian | MI |
| OF | Billy Goodall ** | Jr. | Mount Union | OH |
| OF | Ian Kobernick | Sr. | Kalamazoo | MI |
| OF | Nick Vento | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| DH | Mitchel Yard | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| UT | Derek Helbing | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| P | Phil Mary ** | So. | Mount Union | OH |
| P | Riley Groves | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| P | Tommy Parsons | Jr. | Adrian | MI |
| RP | TJ Storer ** | Jr. | Ohio Northern | OH |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Brendan Mapes | So. | Oberlin | OH |
| 1B | David Lemley | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| 1B | Eric Elkus | Sr. | Earlham | IN |
| 2B | Scott Sada | So. | Penn State Behrend | PA |
| 2B | Tyler Reis | So. | Waynesburg | PA |
| SS | Ryan Dorow | Sr. | Adrian | MI |
| SS | Nick Gatins | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| SS | Matthew McCourt | So. | Mount Aloysius | PA |
| OF | Nate Lynch | Sr. | Earlham | IN |
| OF | David Burnside | So. | Rose Hulman | IN |
| OF | Jack Thompson | Sr. | DePauw | IN |
| UT | Ryan Orr | Jr. | Kalamazoo | MI |
| UT | Mike Hammel | Sr. | DePauw | IN |
| P | Caleb Norton ** | Sr. | Otterbein | OH |
| P | Howie Smith | Sr. | Earlham | IN |
| P | Phil Myers | So. | Penn State Behrend | PA |
| P | Craig Prince ** | Jr. | Otterbein | OH |
| P | Pierce Banks | Fr. | Adrian | MI |
| P | Evan Lovick ** | Jr. | Baldwin Wallace | OH |
| P | David Stover ** | Jr. | Marietta | OH |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| 1B | Tyler Holland | So. | Pitt-Greensburg | PA |
| 2B | Ben Laumann | Jr. | Thomas More | KY |
| 2B | Evan Long ** | Sr. | Heidelberg | OH |
| 3B | Zach Trusk | Sr. | Rose-Hulman | IN |
| OF | JP Batts | Sr. | Hope | MI |
| OF | Jake Fling | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| OF | Tanner Johnson | Jr. | Denison | OH |
| OF | Luis Navedo | Sr. | La Roche | PA |
| OF | Brian Carney | Sr. | Oberlin | OH |
| P | Nick Bucci | So. | Thiel | PA |
| P | Jordan Clark | So. | Franklin | IN |
| P | Nanak Saran | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| P | Michael Herrmann | Sr. | Wabash | IN |
| P | Michael Houdek | Sr. | Wooster | OH |
| P | Jake Shields | Sr. | Case Western Reserve | OH |
| Mideast Position Player of the Year: Michael Wielansky, So., SS, Wooster | ||||
| Mideast Pitcher of the Year: Phil Mary, So., Mount Union (RELEASE) | ||||